Writing / Trans-African journey
Photograph Not “Taken”: Makoko, Lagos
A photographer reflects on refusing the image, and on the responsibility of making one.
“Documentary is a little like horror movies, putting a face on fear and transforming threat into fantasy, into imagery. One can handle imagery by leaving it behind. (It is them, not us.)”
Martha Rosler
List of Photographs Not Taken
1. Three small plastic barrels with fish in the throes of death, Makoko, Lagos. 9 June, 2014.
2. Discharge of waste in the waterway, Makoko, Lagos. 9 June, 2014.
3. Seven naked Ileje children gleefully expressing their happiness at the novelty of seeing “Yabo” a white man passing through their community, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
4. Silhouetted figure of a mother and child in canoe, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
5. Two naked Ileje children waving, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
6. Gesture of refusal, Ileje woman in a canoe shielding her face from the camera’s unwelcome gaze, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
7. Group of Ileje Women and children sitting in an empty school house, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
8. Confrontation number 1, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
9. Confrontation number 2, Makoko, Lagos, 9 June 2014.
10. Shirtless Ileje man wading through narrow water way, Makoko, Lagos. 9 June, 2014.
Central to the hegemony of Western ideology is the continuing insistence that crisis driven identities and values are produced “there.” Under such circumstances, artistic strategies increasingly become a powerful force for creating the ideological and affective regimes central to inhibiting this dominant hegemony. In photographing the complexities of Africa’s real challenges, “good intentions” are insufficient. This faulty logic has yielded disastrous results too numerous to recite here.
We arrived for a tour (read-Poverty Porn) of Makoko on Monday, June 9th at 4pm. Makoko is a community built on a system of intricate stilts floating above the waters of Lagos Lagoon. Its inhabitants are migrants from Togo and the Republic of Benin whose precarious condition of living is compounded by legal and structural insecurity. As recent as 2012 the Lagos State government attempted a forced expulsion with plans still in place to dislocate the migrants. Travel in Makoko by canoe is through canals of sewage, waste dumps, and architectural structures in ill repair with no infrastructural or administrative support from local government.
Our very presence and the circumstances under which we had secured access were an invasion. We plodded forward in shocking ignorance assuming two or three individuals represented a community and could sanction our visit. I felt akin to countless others privileged enough to depart with aestheticized photographs of incredible strife. Had we secured proper permission other critical issues would still remain. I was confronted with the debilitating prospects of a cultural space whose documentation, if done through the conventions of documentary practices, yields images that continue to dominate the popular imagination of what constitutes Africa: naked children, detritus, and the clever repurposing of materials, etc. An essential caveat is that economically disenfranchised communities such as Makoko cannot be read exclusively in the negative, as strictly chaotic or melancholic, as though identities of individuals within these spaces are metaphysically rooted within strife. I observed flights of creativity unleashed which contradicted and complicated the existential vulnerability of their material circumstances. Unfortunately, the nuances of these lived experiences do not flow as easily as a photograph.
I did not take photographs in Makoko. This refusal to document – to disperse these sights into an infinite image flow – is not a naive one. I disavow the “transparency” of the photojournalistic exposure – its ethnographic gaze and inability to capture the “truth” of its subject. All too often this mode of photographic image taking fails to bring about a rupture from the complacency of perceptual habit and visual pleasure that can easily transform zones of poverty into objects of aesthetic enjoyment.
I did not take photographs in Makoko because I could not honestly answer a critical question. How would I represent the lives of a community severed from full political representation without reinscribing the fatalism that seems to accompany visual representations of such spaces?
We have been invited back to Makoko by its community leaders. I intend to make images that do not reify stereotypical identities but render more comprehensive possibilities for imaginative descriptions of precarious spaces and the subjects that reside therein.