Writing / Nigeria / Cameroon / Rwanda / DR Congo
Dream Chamber — selected writings
The Ground Shifting Under Feet, Ways of Photographing, and A Case For Beauty: three prose texts accompanying the photographic work.
Dream Chamber / Lagos–Kigali journey · 2018
The Ground Shifting Under Feet
For this year’s Invisible Borders Trans-African Road Trip, I am particularly interested – photographically – in the physicality of spaces and places we visit.
This physicality, I think, is very much anchored to a certain incessant feeling I have, of the ground shifting under the feet. It is as if the imposed cartographies from many years of colonial interferences are now urgently fighting to reset or refresh themselves, and those who inhabit these topographical construct are ever more at the mercy of its tumultuous nature. I allow myself to think that the conflicts by which the route of our itinerary is marked are a clear indication of this. This is not necessarily a bad thing, on the contrary, it points to a future that looks to break away from the grip of the past. But I say this with a pinch of salt – I will expand on this line of thought in subsequent posts.
In any case, as we travel from Lagos, through Enugu and to Ikom where we will be encountering and working at our first Trans-African border, I am focusing first, but not entirely foremost, on engaging in unorchestrated conversations, small talks, with people I meet on the way. I am hoping that these conversations and “encounters with no strings attached” will precipitate or, at best, inspire images that account for how people exist, occupy, but also break spaces with presence. If an image is successful, it will not claim to be the evidence or summary of a reality as much as it will be a window through which we can imagine what is possible in the context of ever-shifting, complicated identities, and realities.
Ways of Photographing
I think of something Roland Barthes said in Camera Lucida in the way of “the second sight of a photographer is his (or her) presence”. Here in Enugu, I have taken the time to reflect even further on what it means to photograph the public, everyday space. It begins with the question of my positioning as a photographer behind the camera.
Over the course of photography’s history, the camera has had a somewhat ambiguous place with regards to the relationship with people and society. It is understood as a tool through which perception is stretched and offered from different points of view. That’s on one hand. On the other, it is also an ordering tool. Much of the colonial expeditions by which artificial borders became a thing were accomplished through the help of the camera. But the camera is preceded by the photographer positioned behind it. We often hear people say that a photograph does not lie. However, if we should take this saying beyond its face value, perhaps we could allow ourselves contemplate the possibility that a photograph could be made an accomplice to a lie told by a photographer.
I remember some of the thoughts I had as I walked through the streets of Enugu and rode on “Keke Napep”, the yellow tricycles that have come to symbolize the most modest means of transportation in several Nigerian cities. Part of my idea – still tied to my intention to focus on the physicality of spaces and places we visit on this trip – was to experience the city through the spatial consciousness of a local. As Victor took me around, I wondered about my place as an image maker and how this can be accounted for in the images I would eventually make.
Is it possible for a photographer to be non-intrusive where it has to do with a deliberate attempt to extract traces of a people’s everyday life or at best account for the juncture where their lives intersect with mine? I for one know that it is almost an impossible feat. Often times, the people I photograph already know that they are being photographed. They see the camera first before they see me. Their abrupt stares are an indication that they feel exposed. People want to be seen, yes, but they don’t want to feel exposed. The thin line between these two states of being cannot be lost on any photographer whose deepest longing also includes being a sensitive photographer.
Thus, if people want to be seen and not feel exposed, the photographer cannot be exonerated from their curious and often accusatory gaze. For every time I am looked at after I have made a photograph of a person, I too feel exposed or much worse, feel I have been caught in the act. There is a pang of guilt lived for every time someone does not understand why I have photographed him or her. To stand the tide of a subject’s gaze is to make up for the tyranny of my camera.
The camera, one might be led to think, gives the photographer almost an inalienable agency. But this will be only true if the photographer does not make a clear difference between “taking” and “making” an image. For the sake of a brevity, I will say the difference between taking and making an image lies in the extent of the feedback loop in the interactions between the photographer and the photographed. Most times, these interactions are as literal as engaging in conversations, but they can also be as ephemeral as returning a gaze, a smile or bodily gestures which give the photographed a feeling that he or she has been seen. In this case, making an image becomes a collaboration, however non-contractual.
In any case, to achieve the kind of images I have set out to make on this road trip – images that, foremost, rely on the motifs of the everyday space and the compositional attribute of spatial consciousness to give, if nothing else, a glimpse into the hopes, dreams, pulsating energy and beauty of spaces/places traversed on this trip, this “nakedness” – this somewhat disquieting process which renders both the photographed and the photographer exposed in other for both to see each other is, to me, an invaluable indication of presence.
A Case For Beauty
I have, on more occasions than one, found myself caught in constricting viewpoints related to beauty and its portrayal in photography. In my experience, it is almost an inescapable refrain. Here, I would like to speak about this with regards to photography through the lens and gaze of African photographers.
I began my photographic journey exactly in the very first year of the 21st century. Having just arrived in the bubbly city of Lagos from the East of Nigeria, I would say, in hindsight, that I was amongst the lucky ones. With my arrival in Lagos, I practically walked straight into history in its making – a history that is still in the making. Through perhaps some of the most uncanny manoeuvres of my life, I would encounter photography – contemporary photography to be precise – in the hands of some of its foremost Lagosian practitioners.
Today, I call myself an artist. But what does this really mean, especially after my disenchanting realisation many years into the profession that the word “art” is no more than an abbreviation for the “art world”, its markets and its host of inter- and intra-connected merchants? The months I spent at the photography studio, Dolphin Studios, in Surulere as an apprentice to a photographer would bring me forcibly into an intimate relationship with photography. Nothing can give a future, hope, a life, but most significantly, a dream, if it does not carry within itself the quality of revelation. Photography was exactly that for me. It showed a path to wherever I wanted to go – wherever I had in me, in my power, to go.
With time, I would come to understand the medium better in all its limitations, excesses and assumptions. But one thing about photography has always stood the test of time: through it, as far as imagery goes, one can project one’s way of being-in-the-world which in turn implies one’s way of seeing the world. The seeing I speak of here goes beyond the functionary place of sight. It is that which encapsulates a history of individualised experiences; the building block by which one’s tangibility is formed and situated. Through this form and tangibility, dreams become realities as one moves from place to places. Thus, it was in photography that I encountered a glimpse of the ever-receding, elusive aura of beauty. Beauty is elusive because in it we are contained. Beauty is ever-receding because out of it we became, and any attempt to conjure it is as futile as chasing one’s shadow. It is constantly moving through us and with us, like air. Yet, once in a while, it takes on Form. It reveals itself in the most unlikely manner, and places: in a photograph.
Photography, from the onset of its relationship with Africa, was confined to a particular function: to document, order and define a people and a place. In other words, to objectify. When it was not doing that, it was at the service of a civilising mission in a bid to sell one construct/view of the world or the other. Yet, only on a few occasions is the quality of photography as that which facilitates, and by extension articulates, glimpses of an intimate/individualised knowledge played to. Thankfully, today many evidence abound which refutes claims that photography was not autonomously and auto-didactically employed to great artistic wonderment by many African photographers not least those of the twentieth century whose practices predates and, sometimes renders redundant, many of present-day squabbles.
Notwithstanding, for all the talk about self-actualisation, empowerment or self-consciousness, the potency of photography has been greatly undermined when compared to how it has been exploited for the merchandise of bodies and gaze inherent in the Western world’s penchant for prosaically reducing its non-Western counterpart to anthropological and ethnographical subjects – what Okwui Enwezor in his Essay, “Life and Afterlife in Benin: Photography in the Service of Ethnographic Realism”, describes as “the Western popular taste for the strange, the other and the different”. Today, this insatiable taste for the strange and the spectacular is bequeathed to a good number of African artists and cultural operators as the evidence of stubborn vestiges of colonialism.
However, this is gradually changing in favour of a more populated narrative than I may have alluded to thus far. History is in the making; hopefully for good. Nevertheless, something has to be said about the frequent suppositions that to photograph beauty is to photograph affluence more so where it has to do with the so-called “developing world”. In turn, taking the camera and the gaze to places considered of a low standard/ class is being frowned at as antagonistic to the “Black is beautiful” project. This positioning is further underlined by the forced dichotomisations between documentary photography and conceptual photography – the latter being more often than not a placeholder for anything appealing to the conjectures of mainstream media/art fairs, of what African Contemporary Photography is – where one finds willing collectors and uncritical curatorial agents. The former, on the other hand, is now seen only in the light of journalism or humanitarian photography.
If anything, history of photography tells us that the documentary and the conceptual intertwine and are in fact not irreducible to each other, so much that the nearest to any factuality about what their relationship accords them is the status of genres, to be employed, in no given order, by any inventive photographer. Thus, this peripheral bifurcation serves only to detract from the real pursuit: where, but also how, can one see beauty? Consequently, how can one employ the language of photography at our disposal in giving beauty Form and translation?
Where can we see beauty?
Beauty is everywhere. Lift a rock and you will see beauty like in Goma, a city in Democratic Republic of Congo, scorched at some point by the hot lava of a volcanic eruption from a nearby mountain. Today the city is marked by the aftermath of this violent eruption, yet the city and its people have morphed symbiotically with the sedimentary remains of the lava. There is no Goma without the story of once an angry mountain. The people of Goma are as resilient as the rocks upon which they all stand and breathe. As I photographed the streets of Goma, I hardly thought of the people as deprived. I would instead think, for instance, of what a child born here would make of rocks; of the air that first has to filter through crevices charred rocks before it gets to their nostrils; of the Lake upon which the city, their earth-abode, is anchored. Will they think of them as ugly despite being the source of life? I was thinking: if only I could make a photograph that captures an infinitesimal fragment of life’s generosity they feel calling this place home. Their’s is not a life adorned with ostensive hardware and lifestyle, but does that matter to beauty?
Some photographers who consider themselves forward-thinking would be tempted to surmise that photographing in a place like Goma is feeding on “poverty porn”. Indeed it is a valid concern, and they will not be lacking in logic. Besides the detriments of the volcanic eruption, Goma has been and continues to be a crucial playground of regional conflicts in East Africa. Many of the humanitarian agencies have outposts and offices in Goma. And to bring things to a full circle, it is not a coincidence that the first time the word “humanitarian” was used it was in connection to photography.
Yet, are these photographers any better off working in fashion or pop photography when they fail to question the constructs that underpin what they call beauty? And how, say, the mantra of “Black is Beautiful” should be preceded by the question “to whose bid is black beauty”? If we agree that beauty is everywhere, are we not left with the arduous task of figuring out why it is not so apparent especially as the majority of the population of the world, according to accessible statistics, live far more modestly than those portrayed as affluent. Can’t photography find, and serve beauty beyond the esoteric confines of opulence?
How can we see beauty?
Come what may, one will always be at the mercy of photography’s penchant for the spectacular – that unyielding battle between appearance and revelation by which, as John Berger puts it, every photograph is a cultural construct, and by which every image-maker partakes, also, in meaning-making. Yet, it is this inescapable conundrum, this duplicitous tendency of visuality that ought to perpetually rejuvenate sensitivity and purposeful cynicism where it relates to the construct of gaze through photography. It is flimsy to assume that one empowers the photographic subject considered “African” simply by dabs and splashes of colours mitigated by patterned props or background that, at best, emboldens appearance rather than offer profundity of vision.
Thus to see beauty is to be open (and to do so as critically as one can) to Presence and its semiotics – the minute/myriad interplays of icons, symbols, and indexes; the relationship between the signifier and the signified – by which our immediate environment makes itself accessible to us. To see beauty is to break the societal construct within oneself in order to allow for the blossoming of one’s poetry, the poetry of living.
Perhaps this is why in my photographic practice, I am very much drawn to the documentary and the everyday. When I photograph a scene, it is with the belief that everything in a given space is an articulation of our human interactions – how we break and form space-time continuum with our presence(ing). In this case, my conceptual contribution to a given moment is my composure (a feedback response to intuition) and composition. In this light, I consider my photographs as a place holder, or as Susan Sontag would argue, a trace of coded signs of life and living waiting to be decoded and placed in relation to different spaces and time by which conversations and actions become possible.
A truly successful photograph feels like a moment was given and that I was, by virtue of some circumstances not entirely known to me, aligned along life’s regenerative path so much as to receive such a moment. In other words, beauty is the stuff living is made of. It is always under our feet as we move. May we move!
In relation / Writing & photography

Photography / 2018
Dream Chamber
Return to the photographic sequence these writings accompany.
Emeka Okereke · Explore the photographs ↗